Cleveland wins again! Curse of Chief Wahoo sends another Tribe season down the tubes in spectacularly depressing fashion

by Cleveland Frowns on October 1, 2012

It’s not news today given that the Indians’ season technically ended about three months ago, but with Manny Acta just having become a casualty along with so much precious space in what was hilariously dubbed a “contention window,” it’s a fine time to recognize and celebrate the continued success of the best streak going in sports.

Forty-eight Major League Baseball seasons have now passed, along with forty-four NFL seasons and forty-two NBA seasons in Cleveland since 1964, the year the Civil Rights Act became law and the year that a Cleveland team last won a championship in one of these leagues. For the duration of these 134 seasons, the oldest of the three Cleveland franchises, the Indians, and its fans, have clung to the Chief Wahoo logo, a Jim Crow relic right out of Der Stürmer’s animation department that trivializes the genocide of Native Americans and survives as the only mainstream caricature of a minority race in the western world despite the continued protest of the caricaturized people. Now for 134 seasons and counting, there’s no championship in Cleveland and still, as ever, if anybody tells you there’s no justice in the world you can tell them it’s right here in the City of Light.

It’s exactly what makes sports so great. If you’re not some kind of moron, anyway. And it’s also worth noting that the outlook for the Tribe and the Dolans, the folks most responsible for the continued dominance of Wahoo’s Curse, is as dim as ever on the heels of what was as disappointing and deflating a season as they’ve had in recent memory. It’s one thing to keep trotting out your VP of Communications to tell a carefully parsed lie about “honoring” Louis Sockalexis. It’s another to keep doing it even after everybody knows what a disgusting and brazen lie it really is (which of course also explains why Wahoo’s Curse didn’t fully kick in until the Civil Rights Act became law). So now 134 and counting without a championship, and seven straight MLB, NFL and NBA seasons that a Cleveland team has failed to even finish with a winning record since LeBron left town in July 2010 (let alone a single hopeless eighth-seed-type playoff appearance), leaving Cleveland fans with as much to believe in as ever.

—————

In other news, the Hey Mary Kay! letter of the week is from Thomas Jezeski of Olmsted Falls:

Hey, Mary Kay: More of a statement than question, but people are not talking about the unwanted milestone the Browns can’t help but reach this year — 5 consecutive losing seasons (never been done). — Thomas Jezeski, Olmsted Falls

Hey, Thomas: You’re right. Since 1970, the Browns have never had five straight losing seasons. Just when you think things can’t get any worse, they do. But you can bet that after this season, new owner Jimmy Haslam will do everything in his power to make sure it never happens again.

Hey, Thomas: The Browns might seem terrible to you, but the truth is that they are on the verge of the Super Bowl. And while I don’t actually have the first clue what Jimmy Haslam will or won’t do with the franchise once he takes over, let alone what is and isn’t in his power to do, you can damn well bet I won’t so much as look at him sideways if I ever find out, so it will be easiest if you just assume that he’s doing his best.

—————

Which is all for today. Hope everyone enjoyed a nice quiet weekend. Back tomorrow with an extremely important announcement as well as the usual Browns-type things all week.

  • Beeej

    Browns didn’t lose yesterday!!! I’m starting this Monday off right.

  • Hopwin

    I love MKC. Who needs drugs when her statements alone are enough to kick you down the rabbit-hole?

  • ClevelandFrowns

    WHAT IF?

  • http://www.redright88.com/ Tom_RedRight88

    Interesting piece on Deadspin about the Kansas City Star’s longstanding policy of not using Redskins when they write about Washington’s NFL team.

    http://deadspin.com/5947639/the-kansas-city-star-tries-not-to-print-the-word-redskins-because-its-a-racial-epithet

    Be interesting to see how that would go over if the PD took a similar approach to the Indians.

    • http://twitter.com/cpmack Chris M

      So they won’t say the name “Redskins”, but they have no problem publishing pictures of a racist mascot.

      The hypocrisy knows no bounds.

      http://sportsnetwork.com/merge/tsnform.aspx?c=kansascity2&page=mlb/scores/final/boxscore.aspx?GAMEID=35103

      • http://www.redright88.com/ Tom_RedRight88

        I wonder what the thinking is behind not using Redskins but being OK with Indians?

        • http://twitter.com/cpmack Chris M

          “Indians” isn’t an inherently racist term, though. I’m just a little surprised that they didn’t include Chief Wahoo with “Redskins” as two racist items.

      • GrandRapidsRustlers

        This is odd to me because I remember this being a BIG DEAL back when they originally said they would not publish the image in their paper.

        http://groups.yahoo.com/group/TurtleIslandNativeNetwork/message/619

    • manc

      The success of My Beloved Redskins over the years tends to puncture the whole curse of Chief Wahoo idea. You know why the Indians and Browns have sucked? Horseshit decision-making by various frontoffices/regimes.

      • ClevelandFrowns

        Wrong. Wahoo and the Redskins are night and day. We’ve been over this before. http://www.clevelandfrowns.com/2010/03/sam-bradford-the-washington-redskins-and-a-good-question/

        • manc

          Great. So there’s no real problem with the name Redskins.

          Frowns, you seem like a fairly intelligent guy. You couldn’t possibly believe your own bilgewater regarding a curse on Cleveland sports because of Chief Wahoo. My perspective as an “outsider” wrt Cleveland sports is that all the teams (particularly the Browns and Indians) have been horribly run by a collection of cutthroats and poltroons over multiple decades. The idea and promotion of a curse seems (to me anyway) to play into a woe-is-me, woe-is-Cleveland, we suck so why try cultural defensiveness that permeates NE Ohio.

          Anyhow…take UNC over Virginia Tech this weekend. My Hokies are NOT good this year. Bad O-line, no depth in the secondary.

          • ClevelandFrowns

            1. The point is that whatever the problems with the name Redskins, they’re not as bad as the problems with Wahoo, as the above link (and a few Super Bowls) conclusively proves (see e.g., the fact that natives commonly used the term to describe themselves; see also the fact that black people are called “black,” white people are called “white,” etc.).

            2. I do believe in karma. That and my guns is what keeps me going.

            3. The recognition of Wahoo’s Curse for what it is is actually the opposite of “woe is me we suck so why try” whatever it is that you’ve diagnosed NE Ohio with from wherever you are. The Jim Crow relic is what sucks, and we absolutely should try getting rid of it. But until enough people get it, all we can do is celebrate the Curse’s victories, which is also the exact opposite of “woe is me” so you’re double wrong.

            4. Your UNC over Virginia Tech essay is at least 90 words too short.

          • acto

            Frownie dig you move to Paris?

          • manc

            I dunno man…anytime you ascribe human events to the “supernatural” you give people the option of throwing their hands up and saying “well, it’s Wahoo’s will, so why try to change anything.”

            Look, the curse doesn’t exist. What does exist is a great sports town/region get absolutely hammered over the years by lousy management.

          • ClevelandFrowns

            ???

            Who’s saying anything about supernatural? What’s not perfectly natural about karma? Every action has an equal and opposite reaction.

          • Defenestration

            Because now people will know that there is something to try to change. Namely the offensive caricature.

  • BIKI024

    Future’s new hit single: Terry Francona

    Terry Francona, Terry Francona, Terry Francona, Terry Francona
    check up out my ears
    Terry Francona, Terry Francona, Terry Francona
    i’m bout to cop the Porsche
    Terry Francona, Terry Francona, Terry Francona
    you leave me no choice, take em to
    Terry Francona, Terry Francona, Terry Francona

    • ClevelandFrowns

      Superfan!

  • dwhalen5

    is that Arnold Jackson drinking one of Mr. Drummond’s beers at a tribe game? looks like it.

  • dubbythe1

    is it me or was Don cheadle a tribe fan as a child?

    • Hopwin

      Racist.

  • bupalos

    Before I realized that collective punishment is the whole of justice, your apparent delight in the suffering of the innocent seemed somehow counterproductive. Then as I was selecting films for family movie night with the Bupettes it all became clear.

    • ClevelandFrowns

      Exactly. If you’re not a part of the solution you’re part of the problem.

  • nj0

    This may be the most depressing Indians season since ’97. Even after ’07 you had ’08 to look forward to. After ’08, you still had a quality core so you could lie to yourself about improvement. From ’09 on, there were prospects and the future and what if?

    And now? Nothing. No hope, no future. Just nothing. I’d rather be an Astros fan right now.

  • CleveLandThatILove

    Without the sign, you wouldn’t know where they were or who they were cheering. Merchandizing sure has come a long way.

    • http://www.autismspeaks.org/ PML

      They’re going to funky town.

      • CleveLandThatILove

        I was a nerdy teen in the 70′s, need I say more?

        • http://www.autismspeaks.org/ PML

          Far out! Groovy. Or is that the 60′s?

          • dubbythe1

            more Scooby Doo.

    • Beeej

      Wow! I thought something seemed “off” about the pick. You’re absolutely right.

      • nj0

        Maybe the people smiling at a Tribe game?

  • http://www.autismspeaks.org/ PML

    This may have been pointed out here already, but the only two winless teams in the NFL right now also have the NFL’s most inept head coaches, and one of them is because they lost their real one for the season. Cripes.

    • AlvaroEspinoza10

      right on. as a Cleveland native now living in New Orleans, the Saints have grown to be my 2nd favorite team over the last few years. i havent sold out, though, as easy as it would be. one of my few positive browns memories of the last decade was watching mangini beat the super bowl champs by 17 in the superdome. REGGIE!

      typically, i go to a small bar where everyone watches the saints but the bartender will put the browns on a small tv for me in the corner. so ive seen every game of both teams over the past few years. switching my eyes back and forth between Browns and Saints games makes me even more miserable at being a Browns fan because watching a team play at the saints’ level every week is awesome. turns out a team that can actually score points is a lot of fun to watch.

      now this season is just a double gut punch

      and ive seen some national pundits joke about Goodell not being able to show his face during super bowl week in New Orleans this year. but that shit is no joke. people get got in new orleans and there are “WANTED” posters with Goodell’s face pretty much everywhere

      • ClevelandFrowns

        REGGIE!

      • Shadow_play

        Between The Saints poor showing this season and The Colts poor showing last season it appears there is Super Bowl Host City Curse.

        • AlvaroEspinoza10

          the curse this year is named Goodell

  • WestPalm27

    Essay pick, couldnt post to week 5 thread.

    Dallas -3.5 vs. Chicago
    What a shitty day to be an NFL quarterback and play in front of a nationally televised audience.  This one could get brutal.  Both offensive lines LOVE to offer their QB’s up for sacrifice and both defenses are happy to indulge.  I am actively rooting for Demarcus Ware to tear Jay Cutler’s head off.  I don’t think there is one player in the NFL who irks me as much as Jay Cutler.  I’m sure we all saw Cutler yelling and pushing his offensive lineman 2 weeks ago.  It was such a pu$$y move and I wish J’Marcus Webb would have dropped him right there.  Plus he looks like Phil Hellmuth, another crybaby asshole.  If you google “Jay Cutler Phil Hellmuth” you will find that they rank pretty high on the “Most Punchable Faces In Pro Sports” list.
     
    http://bleacherreport.com/articles/786021-50-most-punchable-faces-in-professional-sports#/articles/786021-50-most-punchable-faces-in-professional-sports/page/40
     
    In fact, I would rather pass around a dirty needle with Wilford Brimley and Paula Deen then watch Jay Cutler play football.  But I’ll still watch.  I can’t really see the Bears putting together many drives tonight, even if Forte plays.  I just don’t see Cutler getting it done when he’s lying flat on his back.  Romo and the Cowboys will have just as many problems on offense but at least they have more weapons.  They are really going to have to try and pound Demarco Murray early and often just to keep Chicago honest.  They are going to be coming with everything at Romo.  This could be a 14-10 type of game.

    • ClevelandFrowns

      I’m going to take the Bears +3.

      As you note, both offensive line/QB combos are frightening against these front sevens, and Claiborne and Carr on the corners against Cutler scare me more than Tillman and Jennings do against Romo (even with Jennings leading the league in INTs), but call that at least something of a wash, especially with Spencer out.

      The Cowboys seem to be the public favorite here, but the Bears pretty well handled the Colts and Rams, and that was a really tough spot for them in Lambeau for a night game against a Packers team that had its ass handed to it the week before. Much tougher than the Cowboys had against the Giants in the opener. In the end, I’m expecting more Cowboys-type dumpster fire things than Bears-type dumpster fire things tonight. Hester against Dallas’s terrible kick coverage units could be big (David Wilson might have been the man most responsible for last night’s Giants cover, btw), and it just feels right to fade the Cowboys when they play on national tv in the Jerrydome.

      • http://twitter.com/JRichTCF Jeff Rich

        “I’m expecting more Cowboys-type dumpster fire things than Bears-type dumpster fire things tonight.”

        Ding ding ding.

        • ClevelandFrowns

          I don’t know much, but I know about dumpster fires.

  • fatscatback

    Are we going to get a review and/or comments on CLEVELAND ’95: A FOOTBALL LIFE that is airing on the NFL Network this Wednesday?

    With the long layoff between Thursday and Sunday seems like a good opportunity to go multimedia around these parts.

    • ClevelandFrowns

      Yes I hope to watch it and get something up here on it. Is NFL Network available on Time Warner cable yet?

      • fatscatback

        I don’t have Time Warner, so I cannot say for sure–but they did just work out a deal in the past week or so.

      • p_forever

        yep. for about a week now.

      • manc

        Yes. Watched NFL Redzone on Sunday. Magnificent.

    • p_forever

      if you prefer your brownie features live, you can also check out the kardiac kid, at the cleveland public theatre oct. 4-20. it’s about the 1980 season so it’s potentially more hopeful than the cleveland ’95 movie (because, as far as debacles go, losing a game is nowhere near as bad as losing your team). and there’s free beer after the friday shows (because what can go wrong when cleveland fans are offered free or radically cheap beers).

      http://www.cptonline.org/theater-show.php?id=187

      • acto

        p_4,
        I can not believe someone wrote a play about that season.
        I can still remember yelling “No No No” when Sipe released that pass, the snow, my brother in law grabbing my sweater, (cold as hell and I am just wearing my favorite pink and white sweater, kids are dum),and that horrible feeling when my youthful dreams were crashed.
        Run the ball and kick the damn field goal.
        I decided that day that I was going to leave Cleveland and move somewhere warm. I left eight months later.

        I wish I could see that play. I must be a glutton for punishment.

        Please post a synopsis and review if you see that play.
        I have a special place in my heart for plays, especially musicals. I wish it was a musical. I have been in more musicals than I can count.
        I know, rather odd for a straight guy. It is really strange being Tony and singing:
        “When you’re a jet,
        you’re a jet all the way
        From you’re first cigarette
        To your’re last dyin’ day”
        Then looking over at your fellow gang members with their highlights, low-lights, manicures and seeing their loving boyfriends just beyond the footlights.
        It gets hard to keep imagining that you’re tough guy gang “has your back”.
        No wonder he died.

        • p_forever

          Acto-i love everything about this post.
          It’s a one man show, apparently. There might be singing – who knows? The author is also the actor; however, you clearly would have been perfect for the role.

          And yes – I will certainly post a review and synopsis if I see it – but I doubt anything in the play will be as forceful a reminder of how that season shaped our common destiny as your post is.

  • Bryan

    Has any team with a racist mascot won a championship in the post Civil Rights Act era?

    • acto

      atl braves, among many others

      • Bryan

        Interesting. This raises issues for the Curse of Chief Wahoo hypthesis.

        • ClevelandFrowns

          No it doesn’t. The Braves, Redskins, Seminoles, all of them use a dignified representation as a logo. Not a sambo caricature. That’s the difference.

          • DocZeusX

            “Dignified’ logo or not, Redskins is a terrible racial epithet. It’s always offensive and highly problematic. It may not be worse than Chief Wahoo but it’s in no way “better.”

          • ClevelandFrowns

            It is for sure better for the reasons explained. You’re just repeating a conclusion.

  • GrandRapidsRustlers

    Let me give MKC an idea for her next “What is the first thing that Haslam should do when he officially takes over columns”. We have only had about 2,000 of those in the last month.

    I think it is real simple.

    1. Call Mr. Dolan over for dinner. Have a nice little chat with him about Wahoo and the curse. (Don’t worry about Mr. Haslam saying the wrong thing. He has an earpiece in and Frowns is in the kitchen.) Offer to pay for anything that Mr. Dolan has to do to make the change.

    Side Note: You lose nothing by changing everything. You make money with a new team and new logo. Tradition be damned I mean the Browns are going to have a logo on their helmet soon. Deal. Life goes on. We have bigger fish to fry and this curse sucks.

    2. Fire Pat Shurmur.

    3. Profit.

    4. Championships.

    • Beeej

      Liked for Underpants Gnomes reference.

  • Dinger63

    Forget the curse. That’s a hackneyed rip-off from so many other organizations that to call it a curse is like calling any imbroglio a “something, anything-gate.” Fact is that you (and I don’t know how old you are), like myself (I am 49), are fearful of never experiencing a Cleveland-based championship in any major sport. I was alive in ’64, but I know nothing other than what I have read. I feel no attachment to that championship even though technically I was a alive. And to be honest my passion for sports has waned as I’ve aged to the point that my “passion window” has almost past and I don’t feel the same pulsations that I did when Sipe threw his INT against the Raiders or when that toothy douche bag Elway rescued the Broncos. So I guess I’d say that to connect your personal dislike of Chief Wahoo to the global failure of all local sports teams during your turn on this planet is a tad self-serving and completely dissociative. I don’t care what is done with Chief Wahoo as a symbol of the Cleveland Indians, but I would not assume that removing that symbol from any Tribe representation would lead to an immediate championship for any Cleveland team; and if it did I would simply call it coincidence.

Previous post:

Next post: