The Cleveland Browns are impervious to rebranding

by Cleveland Frowns on March 5, 2015

Last week the Browns made national headlines and put the local news cycle on freeze with a heavily promoted “rebranding” that turned out not to be a rebranding at all. For all the many ways this offseason has somehow again plunged the franchise to new depths of league-laughingstock status, the “rebranding” episode was actually glorious, and a much-needed reminder of how great it can be to be a Browns fan.

To review, the organization undertook what it announced as a two-year design process that resulted mainly in turning its primary logo from an orange football helmet to a slightly redder-orange football helmet.

RebrandedWhile national responses to the redesign ranged mostly from disappointment (“Completely underwhelming,” said the Washington Post’s Matt Bonesteel) to mockery, (“50 shades of orange!,” said pretty much everyone else) many locals were properly relieved.

Given owner Jimmy Haslam’s well-documented drive to squeeze every last penny out of his business ventures, humanity be damned, it was little surprise that he wanted to print up some newly branded merchandise to sell shortly upon taking control of the Browns in 2012. Yet, that anyone still identifies as a Browns fan at all after Art Modell’s theft of the franchise to Baltimore and the ensuing decade and a half of impossible failure on the field is proof enough that the Browns already had the strongest brand in the history of commerce.

That the logo would remain so much in tact after this clash of unstoppable force with immovable object is a testament to how great it can be when something original is allowed to stay that way.

The Browns are the only team in the NFL that doesn’t wear a symbol on its helmet, and the only one named after a person, the legendary coach Paul Brown — founding father of American football who won seven league championships in Cleveland before being fired by (of course) Art Modell. Yet Brown was uncomfortable with his status as the franchise’s namesake, so for a long time the Browns intentionally obscured the origin of the name, at one point pushing the story that it was inspired by world famous boxing champ Joe Louis, “the Brown Bomber.” Paul Brown’s image has never been used as a logo or a mascot for the franchise, which, in the 1940s adopted “Brownie the Elf” as an official symbol, representative of the mythical “Brownie” creatures of Scottish and English folklore “who helped out with household chores as long as you left them little goodies to eat.” The Browns name also evokes legendary running back Jim, as well as the earthiest of colors, brown, prominently featured on the team’s uniforms.

brown

Because the Browns name never came to be singularly connected to any of these concepts, it came to mean more than anything, just, “Cleveland football.” The plain orange helmets came to mean the same thing. And for generations of fans who’ve grown up never really knowing what a “Brown” is, “Cleveland football” and the plain orange helmets have always been plenty. For many of us, it’s unthinkable that “Cleveland football” could ever be anything else.

As for why this is so, inertia is surely part of the answer, as is Northeast Ohio’s status as the birthplace of professional football. But it’s also worth considering that the some of the world’s most successful religions teach the cultivation of a wordless state of mind as a necessary step to enlightenment or salvation. Of course, to really know anything is to know it in a way that can’t be fully described with words. And at some point words, and the labels we make with them, only get in the way. Have you ever met a stranger at a party or on a bus or airplane, and noticed that your interaction was more meaningful because for whatever reason questions like, “where are you from?” or “what do you do for a living?” never came up?

Which is to say that in the absence of a label or concept to interfere, like, say, a jungle cat that has nothing really to do with a place like Cincinnati or Detroit, “Cleveland football” has been allowed to define itself more purely as exactly what it is, whatever it is. Here we can be sure that a critical mass of Browns fans still knows Cleveland football as a lot more than just the last two decades of failure and heartbreak. Also more than the ancient championship run and the rest of the historical on-field results, more than all the people who are responsible for those results, and more than the sum of the rest of Browns fans’ memories of certain Sundays and the odd Saturday, Monday or Thursday in Northeast Ohio and wherever else. At some point, authentic self-definition becomes meaningful enough, and purely so, that there becomes no other way to describe something.

Of course, to some degree this is all true of any beloved sports franchise, especially one with a history as long as the Browns.’ But in Cleveland it’s more so because of the organic simplicity and obscurity of the Browns “branding,” defined over seven decades and counting.

What is a Brown? It’s Cleveland football. What’s Cleveland football? If you can’t tell by looking at the orange helmets, you’re just going to have to figure it out for yourself. Just know that whatever it is, one of the most money-grubbingest billionaires on the planet charged some of his most money-makingest henchmen to undertake a two-year project to “rebrand” it, and the only thing they could really do was turn the orange helmets into slightly redder orange helmets.

Go Browns and go orange helmets forever. The draft is only 56 days away.

  • http://www.redright88.com/ Tom_RedRight88

    Preaching to the choir, but it’s a good one so sing it brother!

    • http://www.careers-institute.tk Essie Cordova

      Google tell you that how to EARN $56258/week??? If you are some intelligent you make many more Dollars.I am also earning many more, my relatives wondered to see how i settle my Life in few days thank GOD to you for this…You can also make cash i never tell a lie you should check this I am sure you shocked to see this amazing offer…I’m Loving it!!!! ☻ ▼ ▼ ▼
      »»»»»»»»» Go to my Account For WEB ADDRESS where you earn DOLLARS…..

      ytertuy

  • tigersbrowns2

    it’s actually 8 championships … 4 in the AAFC & 4 in the NFL.

    • http://www.clevelandfrowns.com/ Cleveland Frowns

      Wikipedia counts 7. What are they missing? http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Brown

      • tigersbrowns2

        wikipedia lists them in the 2nd paragraph – the 4 AAFC titles 1946 – 1949 & the 4 nfl championships : 1950 , 1954 , 1955 & 1960.

        they list the 1950 championship as it’s “inaugral nfl season” …

        • tigersbrowns2

          sorry , the last one was 1964 … typo

          • http://www.clevelandfrowns.com/ Cleveland Frowns

            Right. Paul wasn’t the coach in 1964. Blanton Collier was. 7 titles for Mr. Brown.

          • tigersbrowns2

            if i misunderstood , i’m sorry … but when you said “seven ancient championships” , i cannot distinguish if you were talking about paul brown or the browns themselves.

            we’re on the same page now.

          • http://www.clevelandfrowns.com/ Cleveland Frowns

            Good point, thanks, post fixed.

        • http://www.clevelandfrowns.com/ Cleveland Frowns

          The Browns didn’t win the NFL in 1960, the Eagles did. Pretty sure it’s only 7 titles for Paul Brown. Still not too shabby all in all.

  • tigersbrowns2

    good article … jimmy haslam may be a money grubber , but the man wants to win … and i believe he will do whatever is necessary to do so.

    • tigersbrowns2

      seriously CF , do you think haslam is in this for the money ?? … yes, this is a business & businesses are supposed to make money … but he has enough money for 10 lifetimes. i believe his desire to win outweighs his need for more money.

      but that’s just me …

      • http://www.clevelandfrowns.com/ Cleveland Frowns

        He’s surely in it for reasons other than money. I think most NFL owners want to win, though.

      • Petefranklin

        If there was a choice between draining wallets or spreading happiness, Haslame would buy Roto-Rooter.

  • actovegin1armstrong

    56 days? Oh the draft, it makes me wish to wax poetic and hope that the Browns do not trade up for another Trent Richardson, or plumb the hidden weaknesses of this year’s Courtney Brown, Don Rogers, William Green, or Steve Holden.
    They should see who the can trade to get Mike Phipps, he may have a few good years left.

    • http://www.clevelandfrowns.com/ Cleveland Frowns

      “Plumb the hidden weaknesses” hahaha

    • Petefranklin

      Straight “line” plumb?

      • Petefranklin

        Don’t forget last years two first rounders “towing the line” as well.

      • actovegin1armstrong

        You “get” me Mr Franklin.

  • George

    Excellent post, truer word have never been spoken! Maybe the increase in ticket prices this year was to cover the cost of the marketing geniuses. In the alternative, is it possible there is a correlation between ticket prices and shade of orange on the helmet?

    George

    • 7ryder

      granted, ticket prices haven’t gone up in a while, but I can’t help thinking that, given the timing, the price increases are related to the fines ol’ Jimmy is paying because of the shenanigans Pilot F***ing J was up to.

      Speaking of Jimmy, it is amazing how he doesn’t “know” (wink, wink) what is going with his businesses. First the Pilot F***ing J stuff and then textgate. If true, he sure is lucky Daddy gave him a company to play with, ’cause he’s as dumb as a box of rocks.

  • Nick

    The Tao of Brown.

    • actovegin1armstrong

      Nick,
      I said Dao De Jing, of course while adding a quote from Tao Te Ching and I also said Laozi, not Lao Tsu, I do not mind my inane ramblings being corrected, but….. Please, at least have a rudimentary concept of the subject matter and its respective context. Hope that you read “The Tao of Pooh”,

      • Nick

        Katie introduced me to “The Tao of Pooh” very early on in our relationship. It’s been sitting next my toilet ever since. I knew she was the one then.

        • http://www.clevelandfrowns.com/ Cleveland Frowns

          As Browns fans we are well versed in the Tao of Boo.

        • actovegin1armstrong

          Ahhhh….
          You kids are such a terrific couple!

  • @ScottyB330

    The two year process was undertaken with Nike to redesign the uniforms. This had nothing to do with the logo process, other than the fact that any significant changes to the helmet would have been reflected in this helmet logo refresh.

Previous post:

Next post: